mechanical Pain

Mechanical Pain

If you have stubborn pain in a muscle, joint, nerve or your soft tissues – it’s highly likely to be mechanical pain. Mechanical pain is caused by factors relating to movement. It is the body’s way of alerting us when healthy movement patterns are lost within body parts for an extended period of time.

Back pain is by far the most common of all mechanical pains to become chronic. A review of the literature on the causes of back pain reveals numerous mechanical factors that predict chronic back pain. Physical work, awkward working positions, and heavy lifting have all unsurprisingly been highlighted. 

If you understand the repetitive strain concept, you already know exactly what mechanical pain is. Mechanical pain is caused by persistent movements or positions that your body doesn’t like. It is a pain that develops over time.

Your body can do a tremendous amount of work partly because it’s tough and partly through endless repair and regeneration. But your body also has limits that must be respected. Mechanical pain is your body letting you know these limits are being exceeded.

Mechanical pain can be caused by…

  • Too much movement (overuse
  • Not enough movement (immobility
  • Faulty movement (inefficiency). 

Mark (that’s not his real name) was a patient who checked many of the boxes necessary for a high risk of chronic mechanical pain. And sure enough, he had a very bad back, which was a big problem. Having back pain is never ideal, but when you have to carry out literally hundreds of heavy physical tasks on a daily basis in order to put food on the table for 5 children, it is more than just a serious health issue. It’s a survival issue.

Mark owned his own small construction company, building and renovating architecturally designed houses. He still did a significant amount of the physical labour himself, and this was perpetually compounded by the fact that his high standards meant he could never get the staff he needed. All this meant that he worked very hard indeed. At the best of times, this was very physically taxing. But Mark’s back pain had become very severe and persistent, which was making his day-to-day life harrowing. He basically had back pain from the moment he woke up to the moment he collapsed into bed at the end of the day. And in addition to the pain itself, he was finding that dealing with it was exhausting. 

The small amount of good news was that by receiving weekly spinal adjustments and intense acupuncture sessions, Mark found his pain went from a steadily worsening picture to one with marginal improvements, at a level where he could at least continue to function. Yet more a case of survival than anything approaching quality of life. It was quite a desperate situation. I assume every clinician has patients they worry about in the evenings and weekends. Mark had become one of those for me.

In the background to all this, Mark had a major mechanical issue which I had been hounding him about since the first day I met him. This mechanical issue came in the form of the flattest feet I have seen in over 20 years of working with human biomechanics. 

I don’t mean to sound unkind, but Mark’s feet were so flat that, to me, they looked vaguely inhuman. Flat to the point of bordering on a deformity. Even the flattest feet have a very slight rise in the arch under close inspection. Mark’s feet were so flat that the tarsal and metatarsal bones that should form the arch sat as flat on the floor as his toes. This situation was primarily a genetic one, Mark having been born largely like that. But like most flat feet, they had been exacerbated over the years by muscle wasting in his feet; on account of living in work boots and on concrete floors.

Mark acknowledged his flat feet; they were pretty hard to deny. But he was resistant to spending money on custom insoles. And he was also somewhat sceptical that they could ease the amount of pain he was living with, preferring to blame the amount of heavy lifting he had to do. Eventually, though, as is often the case with pain sufferers, Mark got so desperate that he decided he would try anything, including expensive custom insoles.

When the day finally came for Mark to put his insoles in, unsurprisingly, they felt very strange to him. Also, unsurprisingly, by day 3, his feet ached a great deal, and he was experiencing an increase in his back pain. This pattern continued for approximately two weeks. Then on the second Monday morning following his insole fitting, Mark woke up with no pain in his lower back and proceeded to undertake the usual week’s work. (Usually, except for the fact that he rated his average pain level at a 1-2 instead of an 8-9.)

In the background to all this, Mark had a major mechanical issue which I had been hounding him about since the first day I met him. This mechanical issue came in the form of the flattest feet I have seen in over 20 years of working with human biomechanics. 

I don’t mean to sound unkind, but Mark’s feet were so flat that, to me, they looked vaguely inhuman. Flat to the point of bordering on a deformity. Even the flattest feet have a very slight rise in the arch under close inspection. Mark’s feet were so flat that the tarsal and metatarsal bones that should form the arch sat as flat on the floor as his toes. This situation was primarily a genetic one, Mark having been born largely like that. But like most flat feet, they had been exacerbated over the years by muscle wasting in his feet; on account of living in work boots and on concrete floors.

Mark acknowledged his flat feet; they were pretty hard to deny. But he was resistant to spending money on custom insoles. And he was also somewhat sceptical that they could ease the amount of pain he was living with, preferring to blame the amount of heavy lifting he had to do. Eventually, though, as is often the case with pain sufferers, Mark got so desperate that he decided he would try anything, including expensive custom insoles.

When the day finally came for Mark to put his insoles in, unsurprisingly, they felt very strange to him. Also, unsurprisingly, by day 3, his feet ached a great deal, and he was experiencing an increase in his back pain. This pattern continued for approximately two weeks. Then on the second Monday morning following his insole fitting, Mark woke up with no pain in his lower back and proceeded to undertake the usual week’s work. (Usually, except for the fact that he rated his average pain level at a 1-2 instead of an 8-9.)

In the following months, treatments that had previously barely touched the pain got Mark’s pain down to zero. And he was so shaken up by the whole experience that he even began the process of restoring strength to the muscles, which he continues with to this day.

Having had occasion to use Mark’s services years down the track, I can confirm his pain has thus far not returned.

As case studies go, Mark definitely represents a number of extremes. Extreme physical strain, extremely treatment-resistant pain, extremely fast recovery once the underlying issue was addressed, and most of all, extremely flat feet. Can I stress one more time how flat those feet were if I promise not to mention it again?

Another extreme that Mark’s case represents is extreme mechanical pain. His flat feet meant that his skeleton was functioning like a car with broken suspension and poor wheel alignment. All of which was playing out on the unnaturally hard industrialized terrain we call concrete floors.

Our feet evolved to compress into soft ground. Our ancestors walked on sand soil, leaf litter, and grasslands, while we now walk almost exclusively on very hard flat surfaces. When you walk on soft ground, it rises to meet the shape of the foot, and you leave a footprint. Mark had been born with very flat feet in the first place, but this lack of natural foot support had exacerbated this issue 10 fold. Once he had some flexible but supportive orthotics in, they did a good enough job of approximating the support and shock absorption of natural surfaces that the tension his body had been holding was able to unwind itself over a 2-week period. His pain went away after all those years because the cause of mechanical stress was removed. And his body switched off the pain signals because it was no longer perceiving a constant threat to the tissues.

Specific causes of mechanical pain include – poor postural habits – repetitive work tasks – being a couch potato – chronic emotional tension – flat feet – high arches – being heavy-footed –  overtraining – undertraining –  bad training habits – occupational overuse – wrong footwear – strange sleeping positions – obesity – too much sitting – too much driving – stressy jaw clenching – stress postures – teeth grinding – depressive postures – self-consciousness about being tall or having large breasts – bad workstations –  hard ground. To name a few.

Many mechanical pains are naturally traceable back to injury events. Research conducted in 1994 on over 300 Chinese professional athletes has shown that 59% suffered with long-term pain, weakness and relapses after ankle sprain injury. The researchers concluded that stubborn pain, persisting weakness and re-occurrence of sprained ankles was a major issue affecting the athletic careers of those studied. Many other studies have come to similar conclusions.

Many of the injuries we suffer leave us with residual scar tissue, muscle wasting and altered mechanics. Many injuries occur in body parts that were already compromised. Injuries also have the capacity to compromise the body in ways that makes it more sensitive to the above list of causal factors. When injuries combine with other mechanical factors, they form an ideal ingredient in the broader recipe for chronic pain.

If your tissues are exposed to repetitive strain, unhealthy reactions may eventually start to occur. These physical reactions can be viewed from 2 perspectives, depending on how closely you look at them.

To ‘the naked eye,’ mechanical pain reveals changes like – muscle weakness, muscle imbalances,  scar tissue, muscle spasms, joint stiffness, postural alterations & collapsed foot arches.

Under the microscope, mechanical pain reveals changes like – inflammation and alterations in body chemistry, tight muscle fibrils, microscopic adhesions, microscopic damage to collagen cells & fluid congestion.

The wisest way to view all of these physical reactions is as warning signs, not only of harm in real time but of potential trouble further down the track. This is, of course, how we should also view stubborn pain patterns in the body – as warnings!

It is wise to pay attention to biomechanical pain. Approach it as you might a mild toothache or plaque build-up on your teeth. Mild toothache and plaque build-up may be quite tolerable, but ignoring them over long periods of time seldom leads to desirable outcomes. Ignoring mechanical pain is a bit like that. Today’s most persistent aches and pains frequently herald the onset of tomorrow’s severe pain and disability.

Research has shown that genetic factors, lifestyle factors and past emotional trauma are known to determine the likelihood of us developing chronic pain. This is naturally in part due to the influence they have on the body’s mechanics. But it is also true that these variables influence the way our nervous systems behave.

The clue to the role of the nervous system in chronic pain is in the other predictive factors that those back pain researchers discovered. It is not just mechanical factors that predict issues like back pain. Depression, general anxiety, PTSD  and a fear of pain are all known to predict the likelihood of a patient suffering from chronic pain even more accurately than mechanical factors in some cases.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles